High number of norovirus outbreaks associated with a GGII.4
variant in the Netherlands and elsewhere: does this herald a worldwide increase?
Annelies Kroneman, Harry Vennema, Yvonne van Duijnhoven,
Erwin Duizer, and Marion Koopmans, RIVM, Bilthoven, the Netherlands, on behalf
of the Food-borne viruses in Europe network (fbve@rivm.nl)
An increasing number of acute gastroenteritis outbreaks have been reported
in the Netherlands since October 2004 to the Rijksinstituut voor Volksgezondheid
en Milieu (RIVM, the Dutch National Institute of Public Health and the Environment)
(Table). The early onset of the ‘winter vomiting disease’ season and the
high number of reports are unusual. Outbreaks have been reported from different
settings, most of which are institutional. So far, all of the outbreaks
for which the diagnostic evaluation has been completed are caused by norovirus.
This situation may be indicative of a wider trend as several countries have
reported higher incidences recently through the global electronic reporting
system ProMED-mail (http://www.promedmail.org).
Table. Number of norovirus outbreaks reported in the Netherlands
in the winter seasons from 2000/2001 to 2004/2005
| |
September |
October |
November |
December |
January |
February |
March |
|
2000/2001 |
3 |
1 |
4 |
3 |
13 |
11 |
8 |
|
2001/2002 |
2 |
6 |
8 |
14 |
18 |
12 |
8 |
|
2002/2003 |
7 |
11 |
33 |
52 |
26 |
12 |
2 |
|
2003/2004 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
2 |
9 |
4 |
3 |
|
2004/2005 |
9 |
18 |
31 |
13** |
- |
- |
- |
**: Number of norovirus outbreaks reported in the first 2 weeks of December.
An additional five outbreaks are under investigation.
We would like to share this observation, because we suspect a repeat of
the situation in 2002. In that year, the Food-borne viruses in Europe network
(FBVE, http://www.eufoodborneviruses.co.uk/)
saw a sharp increase in the number of norovirus outbreaks across Europe,
and an increase was also reported in the United States. This had a major
impact on hospitals and other settings such as nursing homes and cruise
ships. The large increase in 2002 was associated with the introduction of
a new variant norovirus within the GGII.4 genotype. This virus was first
detected early in 2002, and had replaced the resident virus population by
mid-summer in all the countries in Europe that were participating in the
Food-borne Viruses in Europe network [1,2]. In the United Kingdom, the cost
of the 2002 epidemic was calculated to be approximately US$184 million [3].
In the Netherlands outbreaks analysed so far in 2004, another new lineage
(GGII.4-2004) within the GGII.4 genotype has been found. This variant is
distinct from the 2002 variant strain (GGII.4-2002). Since the beginning
of August 2004, 71 norovirus outbreaks have been reported in the Netherlands.
Of these, viruses from 44 outbreaks were characterised by sequence analysis,
and all 44 belong to the new GGII.4 lineage.
This variant has already been highly active in Australia during the 2004
southern hemisphere winter season (personal communication, Michael Lyon,
Public Health Virology Laboratory, Queensland Health Scientific Services,
Brisbane, Queensland, Australia, 2004). It caused many outbreaks in different
settings and has now almost completely disappeared in the southern hemisphere
with the onset of warmer weather.
Since the outbreak season for norovirus in the Netherlands normally starts
in December and peaks in January, we believe that a warning that a worldwide
increase of outbreaks comparable to 2002 might be on its way is appropriate.
Although data analysis needs to be finalised, we have indications from
the FBVE surveillance that GGII.4 is more commonly associated with outbreaks
in institutional settings than other norovirus variants; this suggests that
the norovirus GGII.4 genotype has properties facilitating transmission,
and thereby has the propensity to cause epidemics.
We are continuing to monitor the situation in Europe and are studying the
difference in virulence between strains, biological background of the mechanism
for its rapid dissemination, and insight into the micro-evolution of noroviruses.
Details on the genetic background of these variant noroviruses can be obtained
by sending an email to fbve@rivm.nl. We
have used the polymerase gene primers for monitoring purposes, and sequence
properties are given below. The FBVE network will monitor noroviruses as
part of the activities in the EU-funded DIVINE project. We would also be
interested to hear from parties outside the participating countries.
Prevention
There are some protocols for healthcare settings [4], hotels and cruise
ships available in the literature. Guidelines in these protocols are partly
evidence-based and partly common sense, and the effectiveness of some of
these measures is subject to debate. Therefore, controlled intervention
studies are needed in order to apply evidence-based practice during outbreaks
in institutional settings, especially nursing homes and homes for the elderly.
Until results of such studies are available, their effectiveness in controlling
outbreaks is not clear for all settings.
With these caveats, the following common prevention measures are recommended:
- isolation of affected persons;
|
- use of gloves and facial masks while cleaning contaminated areas;
|
- cleaning of contaminated areas with disinfectants containing 1000
– 5000 ppm of hypochlorite, carpets with steam. Chadwick et al suggest
the use of hypochlorite at 1000 ppm for disinfection [4], although
recent reports suggest that this concentration may be too low for
efficient inactivation of NoV and levels of 3000 to 5000 ppm free
chlorine may be more appropriate [5,6];
|
- washing of contaminated bed linen at least at 70º C using
detergents, preferably containing bleach;
|
- particular attention to door handles, taps, toilet or bath rails;
|
|
- no return to work until 48-72 hours after compete resolution of
symptoms for affected staff, and education on virus shedding which
may continue for weeks.
|
Figure. Sequence alignment of norovirus GGII.4 lineages.
GGII.4 cons is the consensus sequence of strains prevalent before 2002,
GGII.4 2002 is the consensus sequence of the strain that was dominant in
the 2002/2003 winter season, GGII.4 2004 is the consensus sequence of the
strain that has become dominant during 2004. The sequence is from the RNA
dependent RNA polymerase gene, the region upstream of the conserved YGDD
motif. Eleven informative positions in the alignment have been highlighted
with an asterisk above the sequence. In these positions one sequence is
different from the other two.
