| Introduction
In 1982, an American physician notified the Municipal Health Service
(MHS) in Amsterdam that eight American soldiers had contracted hepatitis
B during their stay in Amsterdam. All these soldiers had visited the
same tattoo studio. A public health nurse from the MHS department of
infectious diseases made a site visit, where he noticed that the tattooist
used extremely unhygienic procedures. He had a bucket filled with bloody
water and a sponge, which were used to 'clean' the skin where the tattoo
was to be applied. He used the same needles for all clients, without
any cleaning in between. To test whether the needles were still sharp,
he touched them on the back of his hand before he started tattooing
clients [1].
In the same year, a survey carried out among all tattoo studios in Amsterdam
indicated that hygienic conditions were universally bad. This finding,
together with the hepatitis B outbreak , supplied the impetus to urgently
set up local regulations for the tattoo studios, working with one of
the tattooists. This gave us the possibility of enforcement. The first
guidelines consisted of ten 'golden rules' for infection prevention in
tattoo studios, but more elaborate guidelines were established in 1987.
In 1990 the guidelines were expanded to include piercing and permanent
makeup studios [2,3]. Based on these regulations a nationwide law is
now being prepared for skin procedures performed by non-medical persons
(expected in January 2006). Here, we describe the procedures involved
in tattooing and piercing, their risks, the content of our guidelines,
the developed legislation and the results of monitoring in tattoo and
piercing studios. We realise that other cities and countries have set
up regulations - for example, after a large outbreak of hepatitis B,
United Kingdom brought in legislation for tattoo studios (and other piercing
establishments) as early as 1982 [4,5] - but by publishing ours in this
journal we hope to promote discussion and further implementation.
Tattooing and Piercing
The English word 'tattoo' originates from the Tahitian word 'tatu', which
means 'to mark'. In tattooing, ink is applied below the surface of the
skin with a needle (often electrically driven). Traditional tattoos,
which are purely decorative, may be applied to all parts of the body,
but a tattoo is usually not applied to parts of the body that are not
usually covered by clothing, such as the face or hands. Tattooists generally
work without medical supervision, and techniques are often passed from
one tattooist to another.
Tattoos for cosmetic, rather than decorative purposes, were first reported
in 1984 [6]. Categorised as 'permanent makeup’ they include lip
outlines, eyeliner and eyebrows, and camouflage for scars and other skin
imperfections. Although cosmetic tattoos have different purpose and are
applied in different settings from traditional tattoos, the techniques
used are the same.
Piercing involves making holes in the body with a needle so that rings
or bars can be inserted. Piercing can be applied to many parts of the
body, including ears, nose, lips, nipples and genitals. Piercing is not
limited to the skin, and many include cartilage.
Infection risks and other complications
The use of unsterilised needles, needle bars and tubes, forceps, jewellery
and contaminated pigments can result in bloodborne infections, such
as hepatitis B , hepatitis C and HIV infection [7-11]. These infections
may be asymptomatic in the early phases and are therefore rarely noted.
As healing time may vary from one week (tattoo) to 9 months (navel piercing),
there is a risk for infection after the initial application of a tattoo
or piercing. The most common causal agents of these later infections
are Staphylococcus aureus, group A streptococcus and Pseudomonas
spp [9,11]. Typical symptoms of a local bacterial infection are
redness, swelling, warmth and pain. Such infections may cause chronic
infections.
Other complications include the formation of cysts and keloid scars.
Local infection or bleeding of piercing cases is reported in 10%-30%
[12]. Allergic reaction to nickel is another common complication [13].
Sometimes piercing may result in irreversible tissue damage. Piercing
of the tongue may result in extreme swelling and/or bleeding. It may
also cause dental problems, including chipping, cracking and breaking
of teeth, as well as abrasion of teeth. Navel piercing is often complicated
by bacterial infections [14], and urinary tract infections have been
reported after genital piercings [15]. Other problems with genital piercing,
in both men and women, are ruptures of the skin and bleeding during or
after sexual intercourse.
Less common complications are allergic reactions to inks, pigments, or
to the gloves used by the tattooist or piercer [16]. A study conducted
by the MHS department of infectious diseases, in collaboration with the
Inspectorate for Health Protection has shown that inks and pigments are
often not sterile. Also, these substances often contain heavy metals
such as lead, cadmium, cobalt, nickel and zinc. One in five inks contained
azopigment, from which carcinogenic aromatic amines can be formed [6].
Our experience is that knowledge about complications is insufficient
among both tattooists and piercers and their clients. The industry is
largely unregulated and serves uninformed clients who have difficulty
knowing whether the tattooists or piercer is using proper procedures
and equipment. However, most professional tattooists and piercers wish
to promote good practice (the cleaner their work, the better their results
and reputation) and look forward to the development of guidelines and
legislation.
General rules for a well-equipped studio and preparation
The studio must have a treatment room, where one can concentrate and
work hygienically, and a separate waiting room. Walls and floors of
the treatment room must be of a smooth and easily cleanable material.
The chair or table for treating clients must be upholstered with a
non-absorbent fabric that can be thoroughly cleaned. The room must
be equipped with a basin with a no-touch hot and cold water tap, a
disposable paper towel holder, and a soap dispenser. A waste bin with
a pedal operated lid must be present.
Information leaflets for studio clients must be available, with information
concerning age restrictions for these procedures, possible complications,
and instructions for aftercare. In the Netherlands, the age at which
persons may decide for themselves to have a tattoo and piercing is 16
years. This age limit is suspended for earlobe piercing but pertains
to all other areas, because children younger than 16 are still growing
and thus at risk for displacements of tattoos and piercing.
Informed consent forms, with information concerning health (including
allergies) must be available and must be signed by the client. In the
case of children under 16 years, a parent or guardian must sign. If they
have signed but are not present with the client, the tattooist or piercer
must verify their consent by telephone. Signed consent forms must be
kept by the studio in a locked file for ten years.
Personal hygiene among studio staff is very important, including clean
hands and proper clothes. Single use gloves should be used during tattooing
or piercing. These gloves do not have to be sterile, and must be disposed
of after use. Before starting with tattooing or with piercing, all pertinent
materials should be within easy reach. When the skin to be tattooed or
pierced is covered with hair, it should be shaved and disinfected.
The use of injectable anaesthetics by the tattooist or the piercer is
under no circumstance permitted. The use of analgesic creams is allowed,
but only if the client’s physician has prescribed the cream. The
name of the client must be present on the tube or pot of cream, which
can be used only for the client in question. The cream must be allowed
20 minutes to take effect. The skin, after removal of the cream, must
be disinfected with alcohol 70%-80% (ethyl alcohol, ethanol, isopropyl
alcohol or isopropanol). Ethyl chloride spray may be used, but has superficial
and negligible effect and its use is discouraged.
The use of the right equipment and materials and procedures
Only disposable sterile single-use needles are permitted for tattooing
and piercing. These needles must always be disposed of after one use.
They must not be thrown into a waste bin but collected in a puncture-resistant
container (sharps container) for proper disposal.
Tattooing
Complete sets of disposable needles, needle bars and tubes for tattooing,
all sterile wrapped, are currently available on the market. If using
such sets, an autoclave is not necessary (see end of this section).
Ink must be sterile and must not endanger a person’s health or
safety (ie, not engender the formation of aromatic amines, nor contain
any prohibited dyes or preservatives). Only single-use ink cups should
be used and they must not be refilled, except for same customer at
the same attendance.
Piercing
Piercing requires the use of a sterile disposable infusion needle covered
with a plastic canule. Push-through instruments for ears and nostrils
are permitted. They must be hygienic, and fitted with entirely disposable,
sterile cartridges. Skin may be marked with a toothpick dipped in a
gentian violet 70% alcohol solution or in Betadine®. A marker pen,
if used, should be used once only.
Jewellery, forceps, scissors and other equipment used in piercing must
be sterilised before application.
An ultrasonic cleaner is needed to remove ink and coagulated blood from
instruments. Special ultrasonic disinfectants are needed, and after use
the instruments must be rinsed with demineralised water. Sterilisation
must be performed using an autoclave with preliminary air elimination
and drying programme, in order to sterilise the inside of instruments
when all air has been evacuated.
Aftercare
After a tattoo is performed, gloves should be removed and discarded.
Disinfectants must not be used routinely after piercing or tattooing.
The tattooist should inform the client that some tenderness, swelling,
and pain are normal after these procedures and that, if infection does
occur, only 70% alcohol should be used and early medical advice should
be sought.
The materials used to make a piercing or a tattoo must be immediately
and properly discarded (needles in a sharps container, other disposable
materials in the waste bin, and re-usable instruments in special cleaning
fluid).
Clients must be given verbal and standardised written instructions regarding
aftercare of the tattooed area or piercing. These must include the instruction
to contact their general practitioner if any complications arise such
as redness, swelling, pus or other fluid secretions, jewellery migration
or rejection.
Needlestick accident protocol
Vaccination of tattooist and piercers against hepatitis B is recommended.
The MHS protocol for response to needle-stick accidents or other 'blood-blood'
contacts must be present in the studio. According to this protocol, in
case of such an accident, the MHS department of infectious diseases must
be contacted immediately, where there is a physician on call 24 hours
a day. The protocol emphasises that although one may be protected against
HBV by vaccination, the risk of infection with HCV and HIV and other
(unknown) bloodborne infections remains.
Monitoring and law enforcement
The City of Amsterdam Health Regulations define the Municipal Health
Services' duty to monitor compliance with its hygiene guidelines [17].
These regulations have been in effect since November 1987. The authorised
health official must at all times be allowed access to any tattoo and
piercing studios for inspection of the premises, instruments and materials
or for observation of a tattoo or piercing to gain insight into the
method of operation. The tattoo and/or piercing studios are visited
without any prior notification.
According to the City of Amsterdam Health Regulations [17], the following
sanctions may be applied if a tattoo or piercing studio does not meet
the hygiene guidelines:
• A verbal warning will be issued after observing a condition qualified
as unacceptable.
• In case of a condition that constitutes a serious threat to the health
of the clients visiting the tattoo studio, a follow-up check will be carried
out after the verbal warning.
• If the situation has not been rectified, the studio will be closed for
the period of time necessary to implement hygienically acceptable operations.
• The closure will be rescinded once the business operator has provided
sufficient guarantees (as judged by the Amsterdam Municipal Health Service executive)
that the business will comply. The term of closure depends in principle on the
time taken to implement the necessary improvements and will thus vary from case
to case.
• A second closure will be cause for permanent closure.
In September 2003 the Dutch government legislated against the use of
harmful tattoo inks. Strict regulations compel manufacturers to comply
with quality requirements. The Inspectorate for Health Protection and
Veterinary Public Health will therefore collect ink samples at both the
factories and the studios for tattoo and permanent make up.
Results of monitoring tatoo- and piercing studios
In Amsterdam, inspection of the studios has taken place since the regulations
were set up, but these were unfortunately not standardised until 2002.
For each item included in the checklist the studio could score between
zero (to be changed immediately) and three points (good). The maximum
score is the number of items times 3 and this total number is equivalent
to 100%.
In 2002, there were 15 studios in Amsterdam, all of which were inspected:
9 tattoo and piercing studios and 6 tattoo studios. The mean score was
89.5% (range 63.9% - 97.4%). Seven studios scored less than 90%. In 2004
Amsterdam had 22 tattoo and piercing studios, all of which were inspected:
10 tattoo- and piercing studios, 8 tattoo studios and 4 piercing studios.
The mean score was 96.6% (range 88% - 100%). Six studios scored less
than 90% and 6 scored 100%.
The main finding of the inspections over the years [18] is that written
guidelines alone are not sufficient to improve safety. Regular inspection
visits, with verbal instruction, are needed. It appears to be difficult
for non-medical persons to understand what it means to 'work aseptic'.
For example they open drawers with disinfected gloves, put sterile jewellery
on an unsterile table or smoke while tattooing. Also, they tend to mix
up detergents and disinfectants: a disinfectant for the skin was used
for cleaning the floor. In aftercare instructions composed by the tattooist
or piercer, we found the instruction to take 5 showers a day during the
healing period of a nipple piercing. On the other hand, true risks were
not always mentioned to the potential client, for example, that healing
for a nipple piercing may take 6-9 months. In general, there were problems
with the opening and dating of sterilisation bags. And last but not least:
the informed consent form is sometimes used as a safeguard more for the
tattooist/piercer than for the client.
Discussion
In 1987 the MHS published the first version of its guidelines for tattooing,
followed in 1990 by guidelines for piercing. Since the relevant techniques
and materials change very fast, these guidelines are updated very regularly.
The number of studios in Amsterdam has increased over the years. As of
2004, there were 39 studios in Amsterdam, including 17 permanent makeup
salons.
According to Dutch infectious disease control law, a patient with acute
or chronic hepatitis B must be reported to the MHS department of infectious
diseases, so that source and contact tracing can be carried out. This
department has not received any notifications of hepatitis B infections
due to tattooing or piercing during the past 10 years. We realise, however,
that hepatitis B virus infections may be asymptomatic and therefore not
diagnosed, or not always reported when diagnosed.
Recently, two cases of acute hepatitis B were reported to the MHS. In
both the most probable source was the same nail studio in Amsterdam.
A site visit to this studio showed clear risks for infections, and we
advocate that nail studios must also be informed about hygiene and the
prevention of infections.
So far, enforcement for tattoo, permanent makeup and piercing studios
affects only Amsterdam. However, a nationwide law, based on the MHS guidelines
[2,3], is now being prepared for skin procedures performed by non-medical
persons (expected in June 2006). Curricula have been developed for hygienists
working at Municipal Health Services who will do the inspections and
training has started in October 2005
Recently, discussions also have started within the EU for a pan-European
legislation, which will be modelled on existing (national) guidelines,
including ours [19]. We look forward to the standardisation of guidelines
throughout the EU, including guidelines for age, use of anaesthetic,
record keeping, ethical standards (eg, not tattooing or body piercing
anyone who is intoxicated or under influence of drugs), and licensing
after approved training. The exchange between the member states of the
name of tattoo and piercing studios that may be possible sources for
bloodborne infections should also be encouraged.
In conclusion, public health professionals have to stay alert for new
fashions that may include infection risks. In order to detect new sources
of infections, a close collaboration is needed between departments of
infectious diseases and departments of hygiene and prevention. Standardising
guidelines throughout the EU and cross-border notification are recommended.
Addendum: In the national regulations, on
which the nation wide law (expected in June 2006) is based, it is advised
not to set a tattoo in a person less than 16 years old and not to pierce
somebody less than 12 years old. Each person younger than 18 years
old has to be accompanied by a parent or guardian who has to give written
consent.
Acknowledgement
The authors acknowledge Mrs L.D. Phillips for editorial review and the
reviewers for their helpful comments and suggestions.
|