In April 2003, a vaccine-derived poliovirus Sabin 2 (VDPV)
was isolated from sewage water in Vrakuna, a Bratislava city district in western
Slovakia. The mutated strain was 87% genetically identical to the vaccine
strain and differed from the wild poliovirus strain by 1.6%, and it was assumed
that the strain isolated in sewage had already gained wild poliovirus neurovirulence
and infectivity. Investigators hypothesised that this divergence could have
been caused by immunodeficient people excreting vaccinal poliovirus Sabin
2. There were concerns that this modified virus could cause paralytic disease
in people.
After active environmental surveillance was launched in October 2003, two
more genetically mutated polioviruses from the vaccine strain Sabin 2 were
isolated from sewage water samples in Skalica, a town 150 km west of Bratislava.
These isolates also showed high divergence from the vaccine strain, and
in both localities the strains had almost identical differences to the vaccine
strain.
VDPV occurs as a result of excretion by immunodeficient patients, but also
by healthy vaccinated people. Tests on 556 sewage water samples from eight
different sewage system branch collectors were carried out, and 72 mutated
strains of Sabin 2 derived from the oral polio vaccine were found. Isolated
viruses were highly divergent: the level of genetic difference of the most
recent ones from the wild poliovirus was 0.05%. Two of these isolates were
less than 85% (84.9% and 84.4%) similar to the vaccine strain, which is
the threshold theoretically beyond which a mutated strain gains the neurovirulent
and infective characteristics of a wild poliovirus [1].
Investigation of the VDPV source
Additional samples from sewage water and stool samples from immunodeficient
people in the Skalica area were tested to locate the VDPV excretors. The
investigation focused on this local area because it had a relatively small
sewage system serving fewer residents.
Test on samples from immunodeficient children were all negative. Testing
of samples from immunodeficient people with B lymphocyte disorders, and
from people who had moved to the area since 2001 is ongoing. All results
have so far been negative.
Polio surveillance in Slovakia
Polio has been under surveillance in Slovakia for more than 50 years. In
the past, polio epidemics occurred in 5 year cycles, the last being in 1953
before the start of mass vaccination with the inactive Salk vaccine in 1957.The
live attenuated (weakened) oral polio Sabin vaccine was introduced in 1960,
the year of the last reported poliomyelitis cases in Slovakia.
Monitoring the circulation of polioviruses by examining sewage waters began
in Slovakia in 1970. Samples of polioviruses and other enteroviruses are
collected throughout the year in selected drainage inlets to municipal sewage
plants throughout Slovakia. To reinforce surveillance of high-risk population
groups, sewage waters from all refugee centres providing accommodation and
basic services for refugees coming to Slovakia mostly from Asia (e.g., Pakistan,
Afghanistan or Chechnya) are regularly taken for examination. Wild poliovirus
was last isolated from sewage water in 1972, and vaccinal polioviruses have
been sporadically detected since 1972.
Vaccination and polio immunity
Inactivated (dead) parenteral polio vaccine has been used nationally since
2005. Vaccination coverage in children has been very high for the past 20
years, reaching almost 98%. The effectiveness of the vaccination policy
has been regularly monitored by seroprevalence studies, the most recent
being in 1997. The results showed that immunity of the Slovak population
to all polio types was high. The proportion of individuals with poliovirus
type 1 antibodies was 94%; with poliovirus type 2 antibodies, 97%; and with
poliovirus type 3 antibodies, 97%. In children aged between 0 and 15 years,
the proportion ranged from 98% to 100%.
Surveillance of acute flaccid paralysis in Slovakia
Reporting, examination and analysis of acute flaccid paralysis (AFP) has
been done in Slovakia since 1970. No cases of AFP compatible with poliomyelitis
were reported in Slovakia in 2004 or in previous years. The last case of
paralytic poliomyelitis was recorded in 1960. No cases of postvaccinal paralytic
poliomyelitis were reported in 2004 or in previous years. The temporary
circulation of vaccinal polioviruses in the population as a result of short-term
vaccination campaigns and vaccination of immunodeficient people with inactive
polio vaccine have probably contributed to this situation.
Conclusions
A special epidemiological situation has occurred in Slovakia, where a poliovirus
contained in a live polio vaccine used in Slovakia since 1960 has changed
its genetic characteristics and differs only minimally from the wild poliovirus.
VDPV can cause serious neurological disease, particularly in immunodeficient
people, and in groups of susceptible unvaccinated or incompletely vaccinated
people. This is why monitoring of polio vaccination coverage in children
as well as vaccination of susceptible people in places with incidence of
VDPV is carried out. In Skalica, the live vaccine was immediately replaced
with an inactivated (dead) vaccine, and since 1 January 2005, inactivated
vaccine has been used nationwide.
Repeated VDPV isolation within a relatively short time period presents
a problem for experts, particularly in regard to the Certification of Poliomyelitis
Elimination in Slovakia as a part of the polio-free WHO European Region
and other planned global activities to eradicate poliomyelitis in the world
[2,3].
Acknowledgements
World Health Organization, for their assistance in carrying out the investigations.